Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Forgive me for asking, but are you suggesting this is a good thing?


I wasn't suggesting anything with my original post, merely stating a hypothesis about how the world is. It's possible to have a fact without a value judgment.

...but now that you ask, yes, I do think this is a good thing. It strikes me as a ridiculous injustice that the biggest single determinant of your lifetime income is the geographic location of your birth. Anything that makes that less arbitrary and more under your control will lead to a more just world, in my book.

Yes, that means that the economic system is chaotic at present and some people are getting left behind. However, it's far easier to pick up the skills needed to survive in today's economy than it was to move to the U.S. and get American citizenship in past generations.


In America social mobility is declining. Just another fact for this thread


How is it not? Or are you saying there is some sort of nationality inferiority that should drive the attainment of non-Americans below that of all others?

Over the past half century, China has brought the most people out of poverty in world history. These are the forces at play.


Depends on your worldview. Do you care about some kid in rural China, or your unborn grandchild?

A globalized economy will eventually pull everyone towards the mean. That's not good news for your descendants if you live in the west.

It's a dark moral place. It's also why realpolitik rules the day.


Inequality within a country is a far greater (inverse) predictor of your unborn grandchild's standard of living than worldwide inequality. There's enough wealth in the world to go around if evenly distributed.


Decreasing inequality between nations is surely a good thing. However, the increasing inequality inside nations is dangerous not just because of a sense of injustice - concentrated wealth implies concentrated power, and concentrated power tends to be at odds with a democratic model.

Also, China may have brought a lot of people out of poverty but they're doing so partially by sacrificing the health and in effect lives of hundred of millions of citizens with pollution way off the safety scale.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: