Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

“The lawsuit says Instacart violated a California law that bars companies from preventing their employees from becoming candidates for public office, among other complaints.”

That’s an interesting right. Does that mean someone who continuously runs for office is de facto impossible to fire?



> Does that mean someone who continuously runs for office is de facto impossible to fire?

No, it means you can't fire them for the fact that they are a candidate.

You can choose to fire them for the fact that (say) they don’t show up repeatedly to their scheduled work. You could even deny them time off they want to use to campaign when they have time off on the books, too, so long as you did so because of legitimate business needs where you would have denied a vacation request even if it was not for the political campaign (if the trier of fact in a lawsuit challenging it finds that you did so because of the campaign, that's a problem.)

I don't know why people equate “you can’t fire people for X” with “you can’t fire a person if X”, but only for certain values of X. Like, you can’t fire a person for their gender, but no one thinks that means you can’t fire a person if they have a gender.


No more than someone with a disability. Which isn’t that difficult if there is an obvious issue not related to the disability.

What gets you in trouble is not being consistent in applying rules and standards. If you fired one person for a violation but you let other people get away with it, it becomes arbitrary.


I wouldn't say so, no. At least, nothing you quoted would suggest that.

Nothing about firing someone would intrinsically prevent them from running for office, unless you fired them for running for office.


No, and what's interesting is why do you think that's what it means or in any way could possibly be interpreted into meaning?


My country has laws similar to this, they mostly side with the employee but judges are not blind to a clear abuse


Reading comprehension is sad.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: