I really recommend his novel-in-verse "The Golden Gate". Such a literary accomplishment, and a real page-turner. Maybe it's hard to follow up when you have such an early success? Actually, I was introduced to it by Douglas Hofstadter, who in the same way has never been able to top GEB, which he wrote in his early 30s.
He's coming up on beating Joseph Mitchell's 30 years of not finishing anything:
https://www.theguardian.com/books/2012/jul/01/joseph-mitchel...