Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> As evidence, look at the election we just had.

The amazing thing is how the right was able to essentially rewrite the history of Jan 6 over the last 4 years. Right after the incident even many Republican politicians in DC were calling for Trump's resignation and impeachment (or at least some resolution that would not allow him to run again). There was a huge amount of alarm in the immediate aftermath. But then the narrative about the events of that day slowly started to turn into "it was just a peaceful protest where a few bad apples got a bit out of hand" (that came right after the "it was antifa" stage which didn't last too long when it was clear that these folks were Trump supporters). Trump certainly minimized Jan 6 (to his benefit) and the rest of the GOP began to go along just as they've gone along with the idea that the 2020 election was "stolen" from Trump (and if they actually believe it was stolen then they can come to the conclusion that Jan 6 was justified as some of them do).



> the right was able to essentially rewrite the history of Jan 6 over the last 4 years.

so when the left literally changed wikipedia entries, what was that? not rewriting history?

to put it bluntly, it’s hard to have sympathy for your case when the left does the same. when will the left stop complaining that the right is doing things they are also doing?

when will the rest of you figure out that parties are the problem?


> when the left does the same.

Thank you for saying something that has me opening my mouth and getting in trouble.

Given that I am a Lockean liberal at heart, I object to describing the entire left as doing the same thing as the right. There is still a portion of the left (admittedly shrinking) whose foundation is based on science, math, logic, and history.

However, that said, I see a lot of similarities between progressives and MAGAs in their denial of facts, shouting down others who disagree with them, and preferring conspiracies and truthiness because it feels better. Magas do carry it one step further in making up case law, inventing legal theories out of whole cloth (textualism), and making choices that degrade the function of socicity that make things better for everyone except stockholders

> When will the left stop complaining that the right is doing things they are also doing?

progressives, not the left. when the right stops being a bunch of snowflakes.

They won't as long as they get a molecule of attention.


You’re mistaking genuine concern with political hay making.

Of course the Democrats call it an insurrection - that’s what their base wants to hear and benefits them at the polls.

But look at what they do in totality - after calling him Hitler the Democratic leadership was wishing Trump a speedy recovery after the assignation attempt.

You don’t wish Hitler a “speedy recovery”.

It’s mostly political theatre. J6 was a riot, but the republic was not able to topple.


>Of course the Democrats call it an insurrection

They might have incentive, but that's irrelevant to whether it was an insurrection. And it was, it was textbook.

https://acoup.blog/2021/01/15/miscellanea-insurrections-anci...

>No ancient Greek would have had any trouble in understanding what happened on the 6th or that it was a serious attempt (albeit an incompetent one) to seize power. Having a leader or a political faction move with a mob (often armed, but not always so) to try to disperse the normal civic assemblies of a Greek polis and occupy their normal meeting place was a standard maneuver to try to seize power during stasis. As Dr. Roel Konijnendijk, an ancient Greek history specialist, noted in this excellent discussion on the r/AskHistorians reddit (where he posts as Iphikrates), “In the Greek world, most attempts to seize power by force tended to take the same form: the seditious party would contrive an opportunity to gather in arms while their opponents were unarmed and off-guard, and seize control of all public spaces.”

(The link author has a PhD in ancient history)

(the "acoup" name is incidental, it stands for A Collection Of Unmitigated Pedantries)

And while yes, the Dems have flip-flopped between calling Trump Hitler and wishing him a speedy recovery, that's because they're spineless slaves to proceduralism who won't break decorum if the fate of US's democracy depends on it.


When someone has to use arguments based on Greek history about what is or isn’t an insurrection you know there is some serious hand waving going on.

The crowd was unarmed. Its actions were mostly wondering around (respecting the ropes!) and taking funny pictures.

At no point was the republic at risk of falling.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: