"Ignatowsky showed that the only admissible transforma-
tions consistent with the principle of inertia, the isotropy
of space, the absence of preferred inertial frames, and a
group structure (i.e., closure under composition), are the
Lorentz transformations, in which c can be any veloc-
ity scale, or the Galilei transformations"
The interpretation of their result is totally wrong although the result is correct, because excluding Newtons' relativity (the Galilean group) is why electromagnetism or c is necessary.
Exactly. The paper is great for constraining the possibilities, but you still need to show empirically that there is an invariant speed of light and we live in a Minkowskian not a Newtonian world.
The interpretation of their result is totally wrong although the result is correct, because excluding Newtons' relativity (the Galilean group) is why electromagnetism or c is necessary.