Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

This is much more reasonable than the "paraphrased" reply in the blog post.

I think it's somewhat dishonest that the blog author used the quotation feature in his blog post, but instead of including a quote he made up his own response as if the kernel maintainer said it. I barely noticed this parenthetical above the gigantic block quote:

> He said (paraphrasing):

Anyone reading the blog post too fast would assume the kernel maintainer actually said those dismissive words in the gigantic block quote.



>Anyone reading the blog post too fast would assume the kernel maintainer actually said those dismissive words in the gigantic block quote.

That's my case. I only know it was paraphrased because of this thread. The quote pulled my attention before I could finish the previous line.


Yeah, the paraphrasing here is misleading.

Ironically the topic is intellectual honesty.


What's the big deal about misquoting here?

The blog post author just liked his version better. ;-)


Yeah, and I might have felt a bit “blind” if it were not for you guys also having the same experience: I did not see that parenthetical at all, probably both on account of the linebreak right before it and the (as you say) huge blockquote.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: