Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

If I bought every song I've listened to over the past 5 years, I would have paid thousands.


I've borrowed hundreds of CD from the different public-city-libraries I've been the past 15 years. In France you're allowed to make private copy of books and CDs :)


There's no way any public library near me has more than 10% of what I listen to currently. They have famous bands and mainstream albums from my country and that's it. I hate most of it.


in Germany if you try to do this, lawyers will show up immediately at your doorstep and will treat you like a criminal


Really? We have Privatkopie, and last I checked CD Audio was not considered copy protection. You (indirectly, via the manufacturer) already pay a fee to GEMA for every device or data storage media that can be used to make them with the assumption you will. Do it.

Unless you thought libraries were a euphemism for torrents.


from Wikipedia

> Das Gesetz trat am 1. Januar 2008 in Kraft.[7] § 53 Abs. 1 S. 1 UrhG wurde geändert, so dass Privatkopien nicht zulässig sind, sofern zur Vervielfältigung „eine offensichtlich rechtswidrig hergestellte oder öffentlich zugänglich gemachte Vorlage“ verwendet wird.

the last sentence says that no public sharing is allowed for copyrighted works

doesn’t matter if the distributor is a library or a torrent


how could they find out unless you tell them?


Then pirate them.


Copyright has issues, but "not paying for any of it" isn't the solution.


I'd consider "paying for the things you like within your means" a better option morally than many streaming sites though.


"Everything you pay for is actually rented and never truly owned" is sure as hell not the solution either.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: