Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Blowing leaves is perhaps not the way to manage the organic matter that needs to be embedded in that soil

You're doing your own reductionism. Not all leaf blowing is to collect leaves for disposal in plastic bags (and I'm 100% for using leaves as mulch where they fall on beds, and also with not having lawns). Leaves need to be blown out of gutters, drains, and ditches - otherwise the road will start being eroded. Leaves need to be removed from paths and patios, otherwise they will stain the concrete, let moss grow, and make the surface slippery. You try doing that by hand on 8-10 properties in a day, on minimum wage, without health insurance (the situation of most landscape maintenance workers in the US) - and then tell me that banning leaf blowers is a good idea.

Leaves on the lawn can easily be mulched in place and used to build up organic matter, as you point out - but that too requires a gasoline engine powered machine. The call should be for banning lawns, if that's the concern - not banning leaf blowers.

(I should also mention that if you don't live somewhere with a real winter or dry season that causes heavy leaf fall, your situation isn't representative.)



How did landscape maintenance workers perform that task before leaf blowers?


You didn't have trees in lawns, basically. Look at the pictures of old English manors - there would be hedges next to grass lawns but the trees were few and far between in the lawns.

The areas of the garden with trees would be a different thing.


I don't know about England, but trees were common in American lawns since long before leaf blowers existed.


They didn't.

The standards to which we maintained things were far, far lower in the past because doing so was much more laborious and therefore expensive.


It works seem that those lower standards have no significant adverse effect. They only impact trivial stuff like aesthetics.


You couldn't slip on wet leaves and expect to sue the property owner back then.


How did people cope before cellphones existed? It's the same as my original point - it's a nonsense question. If you want to create additional work for people by doing it in a less technological manner, focus on the served in the society rather than underserved, who are trying to get a leg up in the economy.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: