Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

  > they'd be in for a costly legal battle.
Microsoft might find itself in a costly legal battle? Oh no, software freedom must be curtailed lest poor Microsoft ever find itself in a costly legal battle for doing the right thing.


I also found it a funny comment because Microsoft employs about 500 lawyers as part of an in-house legal team that is larger than most independent firms. If standing up for what it thinks is ethically and morally right isn't something a multi billion $ company with 500 lawyers can do, who can?


Lawyers have no ability to "stand up for what is ethically morally right" unless they have a legalistic argument for it.


That is actually not true. Many laws, in many jurisdictions, are challenged by defending those who break them.

In fact, in the US, that is the _only_ way for a citizen to challenge a law. One cannot challenge a law that they have not been charged with breaking in the United States.


You can challenge a law without breaking said law first


The EFF.


Spoiler: the EFF also agrees with GitHub that they can't challenge 1201 orders, which is why they are lobbying for law changes.

https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2020/11/github-youtube-dl-take...


Touché! You're not wrong :-)


... do you really expect a company, whose entire goal and motive is maximizing profit, to waste their profits? Because if so this conversation is not worth continuing.


... do you really expect a company, whose entire goal and motive is maximizing profit, to waste their profits? Because if so this conversation is not worth continuing.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: