Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

"First: You don't know that. In fact the neighbours would disagree."

You don't know either. So I guess we are both speculating.

"Second: laws are intended to be preventative. "

Do you agree with all laws on the books? I sure don't.

"I build a campfire in my room and this time it doesn't destroy my building, that doesn't excuse me in law or ethics. I still did a dangerous thing, knowingly and recklessly."

Can you explain to me how having a legitimate business where nobody was scammed and the outcome was a happy customer is reckless? In addition to this, there were multiple jobs added to the economy as a result of their business venture.

"There are fines involved because NYC operates, even its own gloriously half-arsed way, under the rule of law."

The hotel lobby has lots of influence in NYC. It's a very similar situation to the taxicab unions. Some laws should be bent and broken..because they need to be changed.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: