Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I believe we made a misstep with the password. I learned a long time ago that how you frame something for the user changes how they will interact with it. A common example I refer to is a small textarea on a website, and some clients wanting to see that textarea larger to encourage their users to write more in the box, or witnessing a user stopping and editing their post to frame it inside of the available area without going over.

The same with passwords, they imply a word. A much better solution is a pass phrase. As far as the system is concerned, functionally identical. But to the human mind, a completely different animal. A word is a word, but a phrase is limitless. With proper punctuation and capitalization, it has everything that makes a good password good: A-z, symbols, length. Except, being a phrase, it has an edge to a long complex password: you can remember it. A phrase has a beginning, middle, and an end.



Passphrase still implies using actual words, passcode on the other hand does not.

That said, for the most part people who chose weak passwords do so for ease of memory, not because they're so stupid that they think they are only allowed words.


Using actual words isn't such a bad thing if what you want to optimize is password entropy at a given level of memorability for naive users.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: