Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | najari's commentslogin

>>>Why hasn't Middle Earth had an Industrial Revolution?

Because they studied physics and understood that the industrial revolution leads to doom.

The exponential GDP growth is us considering natural resources free and unlimited in our economic model, while there is in fact a finite amount of resource (we've passed peak production crude oil in 2018). This very free use of resource leads to climate change, increasing the pressure on the production of 'renewable' resource like food. In physics, no infinite growth in a finite planet.

Their world sustained civilization for 45,000 years because they didn't have an industrial revolution. Our civilization is ~11,000 years old at best, I'm not entirely convinced the GDP curve will continue to grow exponentially for the next 34,000 years.


I have always had a similar train of thought around zombie apocalypse fiction. If there was a mass zombie outbreak it would be totally solved within five years. Houses would be reinforced with zombie proof doors and walls. Weapons would be available for purchase that are tested as most affective against zombies. Roads would have guard rails and zombie proof walls to keep them out. It would slowly transform from a crisis to a nuisance like wild animals. There’s no reason it would continue going on year after year


> I'm not entirely convinced the GDP curve will continue to grow exponentially for the next 34,000 years.

Are you willing to bet on that? Perhaps with a somewhat shorter time horizon, so we can close out the bet before we die?

Btw, keep in mind that Lord of the Rings is fiction..


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: